Have US equities gone too far this time?

Equities 5 minutes to read
Peter Garnry

Chief Investment Strategist

Summary:  While US equity valuations are high, equities still offer a better long-term return than government bonds when considering the "real" return after accounting for inflation. The high equity valuations suggest lower future returns, but it is not an exact science. Adding dividend yield, buyback yield, and expected GDP growth estimates a 5.9% annualised real return for equities. 10-year government bonds currently offer a 1.5% real annualised return. The "real equity risk premium" (compensation for holding riskier equities) is lower than the historical average but still positive compared to bonds. Historically, equities have outperformed bonds, compounding wealth creation over time.


Equity valuations are back to risky heights

Since the bottom around September 2022 US equities have staged an extraordinary comeback which has pushed equity valuations from below the historical average to levels seen during the 2000 dot-com bubble and pandemic technology rally in 2021. Traditional equity valuation models like our model incorporating several different valuation metrics are good for identifying stretched sentiment in equities but not good to capture long-run return expectations. More importantly, equities are impacted by bond markets because the bond market sets the cost of capital, and thus judging equities in isolation when forming long-run return expectations is not a good idea.

However, if we start our analysis about US equities and whether a storm is brewing because sentiment has been stretched to levels that US companies can hardly deliver on, then let us start with looking at how equity valuations in isolation translate into future returns. As the second chart shows, the higher the equity valuation is the lower the future 10-year annualised real rate return becomes. Of course, it is not an exact science as the prediction interval lines suggest. At the current equity valuation, the predicted 10-year annualised real rate return is expected to be negative, but as the upper prediction line suggests, the return could be positive after all.

One of the shortcomings of this approach is that the combined valuation metric will have a bias related to the chosen metrics and underlying shifts in equity sectors may not be captured well in this model. It is also not the preferred way to form long-run equity return expectations. Let us move to the more proper method and also incorporate those expectations relative to the bond market.

Less attractive but still preferable over bonds in the long run

The preferred method to form long run equity return expectations are done by adding the current dividend yield and estimated buyback yield. For the S&P 500 the current dividend yield is 1.5% and the 2-year average buyback yield is 2.2%. For many multinational companies it is more tax efficient to return capital to shareholders through buybacks than dividends. These two figures equate to a combined capital return yield of 3.7%. Assuming these capital return estimates can be held over a 10-year period the capital return yield should grow with long run expected real GDP growth. This is estimated to be around 2.2%. Adding the long run real GDP growth and the capital return yield equates to an annualised real expected return of 5.9% at the current level and under the assumptions described.

In the bond market things are a bit easier because the return is known in advance. The current 10-year yield by the end of January was 3.91% and US 10-year zero coupon inflation swap was 2.46%. The inflation swap market is a hedging market in which market participants can swap cash flows based on the CPI Index and subtracting the swap rate from the US 10-year yield gives the investor a real return on bonds. In January, the market priced real return on US 7-10 year treasuries was 1.46%. Compared to 5.9% in equities investors are not offered the better deal in the long run in government bonds. The difference is called the real equity risk premium. In other words, how much are you as an investor compensated for taking equity risk (uncertainty about economic outlook, productivity, innovation, bankruptcy, and balance sheet).

As the chart below shows, the real equity risk premium has shrunk to low levels for the period since 2006 and it is arguably lower than the historical average. But if you as an investor care about long run returns and accumulating wealth then the US equity market is still offering a better deal than government bonds. When we look at the chart it also become clear why the equity valuation chart in isolation is difficult to use. In late 2021, equity valuations were very high and one could have made the conclusion that equities were bad in the long run from those levels However, in real equity risk premium terms equities offered a spread of 6%. How is that possible? At the time the US 10-year yield was as low as 1.4% and the 10-year inflation swap was at 2.7% translating into a negative real return of negative 1.3%. Yes, equities were overextended and there was a bubble in certain technology segments, but the biggest bubble was in government bonds because it did not adequately price inflation risks.

When interest rates started rising in 2022 on the back of the Fed’s aggressive move on policy rates, bonds plummeted pushing up the cost of capital. The only natural reaction in equities was lower equity valuations, but also because higher interest rates were expected to push the economy into a recession. That did not happen, and US equities have since moved to new all-time highs in total return terms while US 10-year government bonds are still in a drawdown confirming where the real bubble was.

For the long-term investor a final observation is important to understand. The US equity market has returned 9.1% annualised since December 2004 and US 7-10 year government bonds have in the same period only delivered 3.4% translating into an equity risk premium of 5.7% annualised. Compounding in equities is magic for wealth creation. Bonds still play a role in asset allocation and in private investor portfolios. Especially, as the investor ages and has less time to recoup large drawdowns which are part of the risk you assume as an investor in equities.

Explainer of inflation swaps: If the current 10-year inflation swap rate is 2.5% and you go the swap then get a return stream if the realized CPI Index ends up higher than 2.5% annualized over the 10-year period. In other words, if inflation ends up at 3% over this 10-year period then your real rate return on your bonds would have been 0.5%-point lower compared to the prevailing expectations when you invested but by going long the inflation swap you get the lost 0.5%-point back from the hedge. In normal language, an investor can lock in the 10-year forward real return in US treasuries.

Quarterly Outlook

01 /

  • Macro Outlook: The US rate cut cycle has begun

    Quarterly Outlook

    Macro Outlook: The US rate cut cycle has begun

    Peter Garnry

    Chief Investment Strategist

    The Fed started the US rate cut cycle in Q3 and in this macro outlook we will explore how the rate c...
  • Fixed Income Outlook: Bonds Hit Reset. A New Equilibrium Emerges

    Quarterly Outlook

    Fixed Income Outlook: Bonds Hit Reset. A New Equilibrium Emerges

    Althea Spinozzi

    Head of Fixed Income Strategy

  • Equity Outlook: Will lower rates lift all boats in equities?

    Quarterly Outlook

    Equity Outlook: Will lower rates lift all boats in equities?

    Peter Garnry

    Chief Investment Strategist

    After a period of historically high equity index concentration driven by the 'Magnificent Seven' sto...
  • FX Outlook: USD in limbo amid political and policy jitters

    Quarterly Outlook

    FX Outlook: USD in limbo amid political and policy jitters

    Charu Chanana

    Chief Investment Strategist

    As we enter the final quarter of 2024, currency markets are set for heightened turbulence due to US ...
  • Commodity Outlook: Gold and silver continue to shine bright

    Quarterly Outlook

    Commodity Outlook: Gold and silver continue to shine bright

    Ole Hansen

    Head of Commodity Strategy

  • FX: Risk-on currencies to surge against havens

    Quarterly Outlook

    FX: Risk-on currencies to surge against havens

    Charu Chanana

    Chief Investment Strategist

    Explore the outlook for USD, AUD, NZD, and EM carry trades as risk-on currencies are set to outperfo...
  • Equities: Are we blowing bubbles again

    Quarterly Outlook

    Equities: Are we blowing bubbles again

    Peter Garnry

    Chief Investment Strategist

    Explore key trends and opportunities in European equities and electrification theme as market dynami...
  • Macro: Sandcastle economics

    Quarterly Outlook

    Macro: Sandcastle economics

    Peter Garnry

    Chief Investment Strategist

    Explore the "two-lane economy," European equities, energy commodities, and the impact of US fiscal p...
  • Bonds: What to do until inflation stabilises

    Quarterly Outlook

    Bonds: What to do until inflation stabilises

    Althea Spinozzi

    Head of Fixed Income Strategy

    Discover strategies for managing bonds as US and European yields remain rangebound due to uncertain ...
  • Commodities: Energy and grains in focus as metals pause

    Quarterly Outlook

    Commodities: Energy and grains in focus as metals pause

    Ole Hansen

    Head of Commodity Strategy

    Energy and grains to shine as metals pause. Discover key trends and market drivers for commodities i...
Disclaimer

Saxo Capital Markets (Australia) Limited prepares and distributes information/research produced within the Saxo Bank Group for informational purposes only. In addition to the disclaimer below, if any general advice is provided, such advice does not take into account your individual objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider the appropriateness of trading any financial instrument as trading can result in losses that exceed your initial investment. Please refer to our Analysis Disclaimer, and our Financial Services Guide and Product Disclosure Statement. All legal documentation and disclaimers can be found at https://www.home.saxo/en-au/legal/.

The Saxo Bank Group entities each provide execution-only service. Access and use of Saxo News & Research and any Saxo Bank Group website are subject to (i) the Terms of Use; (ii) the full Disclaimer; and (iii) the Risk Warning in addition (where relevant) to the terms governing the use of the website of a member of the Saxo Bank Group.

Saxo News & Research is provided for informational purposes, does not contain (and should not be construed as containing) financial, investment, tax or trading advice or advice of any sort offered, recommended or endorsed by Saxo Bank Group and should not be construed as a record of our trading prices, or as an offer, incentive or solicitation for the subscription, sale or purchase in any financial instrument. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. All trading or investments you make must be pursuant to your own unprompted and informed self-directed decision. No Saxo Bank Group entity shall be liable for any losses that you may sustain as a result of any investment decision made in reliance on information on Saxo News & Research.

To the extent that any content is construed as investment research, such content was not intended to and has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such, would be considered as a marketing communication.

None of the information contained here constitutes an offer to purchase or sell a financial instrument, or to make any investments.Saxo Capital Markets does not take into account your personal investment objectives or financial situation and makes no representation and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the information nor for any loss arising from any investment made in reliance of this presentation. Any opinions made are subject to change and may be personal to the author. These may not necessarily reflect the opinion of Saxo Capital Markets or its affiliates.

Please read our disclaimers:
- Full Disclaimer (https://www.home.saxo/en-au/legal/disclaimer/saxo-disclaimer)
- Analysis Disclaimer (https://www.home.saxo/en-au/legal/analysis-disclaimer/saxo-analysis-disclaimer)
- Notification on Non-Independent Investment Research (https://www.home.saxo/legal/niird/notification)

Saxo Capital Markets (Australia) Limited
Suite 1, Level 14, 9 Castlereagh St
Sydney NSW 2000
Australia

Contact Saxo

Select region

Australia
Australia

The Saxo trading platform has received numerous awards and recognition. For details of these awards and information on awards visit www.home.saxo/en-au/about-us/awards

Saxo Capital Markets (Australia) Limited ABN 32 110 128 286 AFSL 280372 (‘Saxo’ or ‘Saxo Capital Markets’) is a wholly owned subsidiary of Saxo Bank A/S, headquartered in Denmark. Please refer to our General Business Terms, Financial Services Guide, Product Disclosure Statement and Target Market Determination to consider whether acquiring or continuing to hold financial products is suitable for you, prior to opening an account and investing in a financial product.

Trading in financial instruments carries various risks, and is not suitable for all investors. Please seek expert advice, and always ensure that you fully understand these risks before trading. Saxo Capital Markets does not provide ‘personal’ financial product advice, any information available on this website is ‘general’ in nature and for informational purposes only. Saxo Capital Markets does not take into account an individual’s needs, objectives or financial situation. The Target Market Determination should assist you in determining whether any of the products or services we offer are likely to be consistent with your objectives, financial situation and needs.

Apple, iPad and iPhone are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the US and other countries. AppStore is a service mark of Apple Inc.

The information or the products and services referred to on this website may be accessed worldwide, however is only intended for distribution to and use by recipients located in countries where such use does not constitute a violation of applicable legislation or regulations. Products and Services offered on this website is not intended for residents of the United States and Japan.

Please click here to view our full disclaimer.